ONTAP Discussions

What's the best protocol to use for Hyper-V on ONTAP

swordfish

Hello Everyone,

 

We have deployed Hyper-V last year on CIFS and we have been running into issue with that. One ONTAP upgrade led to lifmgr going into non-responsive state and another was with the domain authentications, rebooting all the VMs. This has led us to think about moving to iSCSI instead of using CIFS. In your opinion what would be the best protocol for Hyper-V and what could be the downsides related to that.

 

Thank You

 

1 ACCEPTED SOLUTION

Mjizzini

Depending on your environment, DC/Network stability, setup and config,  each protocol can have advantages over the other one. 

 

That been said, Since ISCSI is a SAN protocol, It has no interactions with the domain controller.

ISCSI LIF dont migrate. ISCSI MPIO sets up multiple paths between a server and its storage. It provides failover path incase of any link/path failure. 

View solution in original post

5 REPLIES 5

GidonMarcus

Hi

 

I think that the answer is depend on your circumstances.

If you can get the same (or acceptable) performance and availability with other protocol that been proven or theoretically more fit - that's a win.

 

Beside MPIO that was mentioned before. I do want to add that by doing that you're moving what now been your point of failure - to another; Windows clustering... in the last few years iv'e seen the CMS process crashes, indefinite WMI leaks (some recovered gracefully,  required a VM shutdown or just crashed) and lot's of finger pointing between software and hardware vendor when these go south.  yes - the majority is for a single host and not affected the whole cluster, but I did see a few that did.

Gidi Marcus (Linkedin) - Storage and Microsoft technologies consultant - Hydro IT LTD - UK

Mjizzini

Depending on your environment, DC/Network stability, setup and config,  each protocol can have advantages over the other one. 

 

That been said, Since ISCSI is a SAN protocol, It has no interactions with the domain controller.

ISCSI LIF dont migrate. ISCSI MPIO sets up multiple paths between a server and its storage. It provides failover path incase of any link/path failure. 

View solution in original post

TMAC_CTG

I agree that iSCSI should be the first thing to use.

 

With SMB, are you using SMB3 and CA (Continuously-AVailable) shares? You have to enable the option per-share.

If not, that might explain all the woes

swordfish

O yes. We enabled everything following the TR from NetApp to ensure NDA

SpindleNinja

I've not ever deployed Hyper-V with SMB3. Always iSCSI.

Announcements
NetApp on Discord Image

We're on Discord, are you?

Live Chat, Watch Parties, and More!

Explore Banner

Meet Explore, NetApp’s digital sales platform

Engage digitally throughout the sales process, from product discovery to configuration, and handle all your post-purchase needs.

NetApp Insights to Action
I2A Banner
Public