How to tell if Disks fit into DS14MK2 ???

[admchtxpl]

I have 28 disk in DS14 shelves, which I need to migrate to DS14MK2...

Here is the list of disks, some do fit the MK2 and some do not, but I can't fins ANY ifnormation on how to tell if tehy fit without physicall removing them and check if the carrier has the "wide" slot or not. But I need to be able to find out without removing them!

Thanks for your ideas,

Peter

                 16  : NETAPP   X274_SCHT6146F10 NA16 136.0GB 520B/sect (3HYX69Y100007430AL7P)

                 17  : NETAPP   X278_S15K5146F15 NA02 136.0GB 520B/sect (3LN6TRQ70000991571MJ)

                 18  : NETAPP   X274_SCHT6146F10 NA16 136.0GB 520B/sect (3HYX3YNR000074125SGP)

                 19  : NETAPP   X274_SCHT6146F10 NA16 136.0GB 520B/sect (3HYX6W9000007342ZN5K)

                 20  : NETAPP   X274_SCHT6146F10 NA16 136.0GB 520B/sect (3HYX6RFJ000074359RXW)

                 21  : NETAPP   X274_HJURE146F10 NA14 136.0GB 520B/sect (407A7138)

                 22  : NETAPP   X236_HJURE146F10 NA14 136.0GB 520B/sect (40243303)

                 23  : NETAPP   X278_S15K5146F15 NA02 136.0GB 520B/sect (3LN6ZHT40000991572C8)

                 24  : NETAPP   X274_SCHT6146F10 NA16 136.0GB 520B/sect (3HY0Z37N000073476CNP)

                 25  : NETAPP   X274_SCHT6146F10 NA16 136.0GB 520B/sect (3HY0Z7KE000073476CMY)

                 26  : NETAPP   X274_SCHT6146F10 NA16 136.0GB 520B/sect (3HYX4N04000075103Z3E)

                 27  : NETAPP   X274_SCHT6146F10 NA16 136.0GB 520B/sect (3HYX4T54000075046A9N)

                 28  : NETAPP   X274_SCHT6146F10 NA16 136.0GB 520B/sect (3HYX681F000073476CDU)

                 29  : NETAPP   X274_SCHT6146F10 NA16 136.0GB 520B/sect (3HYX89CY00007420UY7W)

                 32  : NETAPP   X274_SCHT6146F10 NA16 136.0GB 520B/sect (3HYX542200007433CX9S)

                 33  : NETAPP   X274_SCHT6146F10 NA16 136.0GB 520B/sect (3HY0YTF100007346G76D)

                 34  : NETAPP   X274_HJURE146F10 NA14 136.0GB 520B/sect (40513102)

                 35  : NETAPP   X236_HJURE146F10 NA14 136.0GB 520B/sect (40246130)

                 36  : NETAPP   X236_HJURE146F10 NA14 136.0GB 520B/sect (404C9707)

                 37  : NETAPP   X236_HJURE146F10 NA14 136.0GB 520B/sect (40246280)

                 38  : NETAPP   X236_HJURE146F10 NA14 136.0GB 520B/sect (40240028)

                 39  : NETAPP   X236_SCHT6146F10 NA16 136.0GB 520B/sect (3HY6MBWH00007507E4Z1)

                 40  : NETAPP   X236_HJURE146F10 NA14 136.0GB 520B/sect (40214566)

                 41  : NETAPP   X236_HJURE146F10 NA14 136.0GB 520B/sect (40231451)

                 42  : NETAPP   X274_S10K7146F10 NA07 136.0GB 520B/sect (3KS0ZCCF00007614QFYK)

                 43  : NETAPP   X274_SCHT6146F10 NA16 136.0GB 520B/sect (3HY8YNDX00007431FC3Y)

                 44  : NETAPP   X274_S10K7146F10 NA07 136.0GB 520B/sect (3KS0SWEK00007540J27P)

                 45  : NETAPP   X278_S15K5146F15 NA02 136.0GB 520B/sect (3LN6WNTH00009915X678)

[scottgelb]

The X274 and the X278 look good for the mk2... However, the 7 X236 drives are not for the mk2 and the carrier won't work since they are 1GB drives.

Use parts finder and search the part #... the SP part numbers are the same as the X part but used for RMA.

http://now.netapp.com/eservice/CategorySearchSubmit.do?csCategory=DISK&csDescription=&csDiskshelf=N%2FA&csPlatform=Select+One&SN=&OS=&Plform=&ASUP=&mo...

[aborzenkov]

As I just answered on support forums ☺ X274 came in two variants; both are OK for mk2, but X274A is 1Gb/s only. Need to check basing on model number.

[scottgelb]

274a shows ok for ds14mk2 in the parts finder and in the RMA description  http://now.netapp.com/eservice/partDetails.do?partNumber=SP-274A&productGuid=47DA9F958AC60072E10080000A63AE6C&rohsCompliant=No  

But you might be right... I remember something about an A model not working mk2 but can't remember that long ago since these are really old drives... but the description lists they were mk2 supported.  mk4 too which is odd.

[admchtxpl]

I get the feeling that I need to migrate all disks except the 278... to make sure the move works next time... I "love" netapp

[admchtxpl]

What is the information in parts finder that tells me that the Disk Carrier is fitting into the MK2 shelf?

When I've tried to move them last week, I had to immediately revers and had no time/chance to get a complete look at the disks... So I need to find this out to 200% which ones I need to migrate with the "disk replace" command.

Thanks,

Peter

[scottgelb]

To the right of the disk it lists shelves. Your x236 are the ones with the thinner carrier key for the mk1 shelf only.

Sent from my iPhone 4S

[admchtxpl]

Yes, thats correct. I do have the impression that NetApp shipped some X274 in the "thinner" carrier and some in the "wider" carrier... Which makes it almost impossible to handle this situation... Correct?